Tuesday, July 28, 2026

Italian for "You Will Be Tormented For Your Surname" or Why I Changed My Name to Match My Face

 Sixteen years ago, I walked out of a courthouse with a different last name. I traded my father’s surname — a name that started with A and ended in a rhyme with “ayatollah” — for my mother’s maiden name, Clark. One syllable. No double letters. Nobody has ever asked me to spell it twice.

I am a third-generation Italian American on my father’s side — the side that gave me the original surname. My mother’s side is English: her father’s family emigrated from County Durham, in the far north of England, close enough to the border that the family’s roots run as Scottish as they do English. My great-grandmother was pregnant with him when they made the crossing. They landed in Washington County, Pennsylvania, where relatives who’d arrived earlier were already working the coal mines. Other branches of the family scattered from Durham to New Zealand, Australia, and South Africa, and nearly all of them went from coal mines to coal mines, like so many other families from that corner of England. It was what they knew, and it was what they were seen as fit for. My grandfather’s older siblings had all been born in England; he was born a few weeks after landing — American by a matter of weeks, not generations. So when I traded my father’s Italian surname for my mother’s, I wasn’t reaching for something invented or aspirational. Clark is as much a real, inherited family name as the one I gave up — it’s just the more recent immigration story of the two. The irony isn’t lost on me: my mother’s people got off the boat and went straight into a coal mine, one generation closer to the docks than my father’s, and still theirs was the name that read as more American. Palatability, it turns out, has nothing to do with how long you’ve actually been here.

And yet the surname I was born with followed a much older script: playground taunts in elementary school, the same taunts refined into something crueler by middle school, and by high school a kind of low-grade exhaustion that never really lifted. In my professional life, the pattern just changed shape. Every new meeting opened with a small tutorial. Even when I said, “It’s fine, say it however you like,” people insisted on getting it right, and the conversation stalled until everyone felt satisfied they had.

My siblings never went through any of this. They have dark hair, dark eyes, darker complexions than mine. I have light brown hair and blue eyes, and I’m lighter complected than either of them. Same surname, same household, wildly different treatment. Their faces fit what people expected a name like ours to look like, whether by stereotype or the law of averages. Mine didn’t. The mismatch was the problem, not the name itself.

But it wasn’t only about my face. I have cousins on both sides of the family — sons of my uncles — who share my exact eye color and complexion, carrying the same surname I was born with. As far as I know, none of them ever got the airport treatment I did. The difference wasn’t the name, and it wasn’t only the coloring. It was that I was a woman traveling with a name nobody could place, and they were men. Somewhere in whatever calculus decides who looks dangerous, being female with an unplaceable name apparently reads very differently than being male with the same one.

Nowhere was that mismatch more consequential than in airports. Before I changed my name, flying meant budgeting extra time for what security always called a “random” check. It had a rhythm: an agent would ask if the name on my ID was my husband’s, and when I said I wasn’t married, they’d ask if it was my father’s or my mother’s. Was it Middle Eastern? How many double letters was that, again? Someone would guess Italian, then ask what it meant. I’d get handed from one agent to the next, each one circling the same handful of questions about my surname, while my actual bag went largely unexamined. Looking back, it’s obvious what was happening: they were stalling until a background check cleared and confirmed what should have been obvious from the start — that I wasn’t a threat to anyone.

The part that still strikes me is that this didn’t stop at the checkpoint. More than once, I’d already cleared security, walk to my gate, board a connecting flight’s queue for the next leg, and get pulled for another “random” check — a second one, on the secure side of the airport, where in theory everyone in line has already been vetted. I never saw it happen to anyone else standing near me, even in the years right after 9/11 when heightened scrutiny was supposedly the norm for everyone.

One of those checks, at the Austin airport, has stuck with me more than the others. The agent working the line that day was Black. He ran me through the exact same script everyone always did — was it my husband’s name, my father’s, was it Middle Eastern, what did it mean. By then I’d answered these questions hundreds of times, and something in me just ran out of patience. I told him it was Italian for “you will be tormented throughout grade school, and by the TSA, for your surname.” He blinked and said, “Really?” “No,” I said. “Can I go to my plane now?” What’s stayed with me isn’t the joke — it’s that a man who, by any reasonable account, has his own fluency in being profiled was standing there running me through the identical script, asking the identical questions, because the institution had trained him to flag exactly what I represented: a name that didn’t match a face.

Then I became Clark, and all of it just stopped. Not slowed down — stopped. I’ve flown frequently for sixteen years since, and I can count on one finger the times I’ve been pulled aside. It was last year, and it turned out to be about dental powder in my bag, which is apparently a bigger red flag these days than a liquid. That’s it. That’s the whole story. A person, an actual threat assessment, based on what was in my luggage — which is, in theory, how airport security is supposed to work for everyone.

I got Global Entry as soon as it was widely available, and I’ve since renewed it; I fly with my known traveler number attached to every reservation. All of that helps. But I’d be lying if I said the credentials were doing the heavy lifting. What changed my experience of flying wasn’t a vetting program. It was Clark: a name that reads as Scottish or English to anyone who hears it, and matches my coloring either way. People hear an Italian surname and picture dark hair, dark eyes, olive skin. They hear Clark and picture someone who looks like me. I didn’t change my face to match my name. I changed my name to match my face.

At least, my winter face. I tan so dark in the summer that strangers feel free to ask what I am. In the Bay Area, people have asked if I’m part Black. At the Monterey Jazz Festival, a couple in the food line skipped hello entirely and opened with “Oh, you must have been in the Caribbean. I always get that tan when I go there.” It was a bike commute and lap swimming. In London, in July, a woman asked if I was Egyptian. Nobody needed my surname to land on the same question the TSA used to ask. My face still owes people an explanation. It just doesn’t have a name to blame anymore.

I don’t know exactly what to call this. It isn’t quite assimilation, since I didn’t change my ancestry, my family, or my face — just five letters at the end of my name. It isn’t quite acculturation either, since I was already about as culturally American as a person can be, three generations deep, with a grandfather born on this soil. But it’s real, and it’s been real for sixteen years: proof that belonging, in the eyes of a security line, has very little to do with who you actually are and a great deal to do with how easy you are to say out loud.

What bothers me, sixteen years out, is how easy it turned out to be. A problem that followed me from the playground to the security line should not have been solvable with paperwork, and yet it was. I filled out a form, stood in front of a judge, and walked away from a pattern of scrutiny with a new surname. Most people don’t have that option, and most people shouldn’t have to consider it. Nobody should have to give up the name their father gave them, the one they’ve carried their whole life, just to stop being pulled out of line. And the irony is that the people with the hardest names to pronounce in this country are often the ones facing the least of this particular flavor of scrutiny — because their names come pre-explained by an accent, a visa, an obviously foreign passport. In professional settings, I’ve watched colleagues wave off a coworker’s name entirely — “we just call him Aleks, his last name’s a mouthful” — with an easy, apologetic affection that was never once extended to me. He was Russian; of course nobody could say it. I was American, and I didn’t look foreign, so my name was treated as a puzzle I owed them a solution to. The bigotry isn’t really about the name at all. It’s about what a name is and isn’t allowed to say about the face above it, and who gets punished for the mismatch.

None of this came free, even for me. My father’s side of the family has never fully forgiven me for it — never mind that most women change their surname without a second thought when they marry, or that my own sister changed hers back after her divorce with no one blinking. My mother’s side felt the opposite. My grandfather’s younger brother, who died in 2016 at ninety-eight, having never had children of his own, was over the moon about it. I visited him often at his retirement community in Oregon, and I think the name meant something to him beyond me just liking the sound of it — a kind of continuation he didn’t otherwise get to see.

Plenty of non-native speakers do their own version of what I did. They soften a first name for the office, go by “Mike” or “Karen” at the desk next to mine, learn to introduce themselves in whatever way costs a room the least friction. But that’s a courtesy they extend to other people, not a fix for their own exposure. Their real name is still on the passport at the checkpoint, and a first name offered up for other people’s comfort doesn’t change it.

I had a classmate from sixth grade through graduation with a long Egyptian name — five names in all. He was one of the funniest, most good-humored kids I knew, and I still remember him at the chalkboard in sixth grade, writing the whole thing out, name after name, because there was no way to say it that didn’t need explaining. After 9/11, he did his own version of what I did: shortened his first name to three letters and traded his surname for one that, like Clark, could pass for Scottish. We made almost the identical decision, for almost the identical reason. But I have blue eyes and light skin, and he doesn’t. My name change closed the case. His changed the questions, but it couldn’t change the answer people assumed on sight.

Which is the part I keep landing on: being able to walk away from all of it was a privilege, full stop. I didn’t earn my way out of profiling. I paid a filing fee and became someone the system had already decided to trust.

None of this makes me less sympathetic to anyone else navigating a name the world finds inconvenient — if anything, it’s made me more so. At work, I’ve made a habit of fixing team members’ names in our systems when they’ve been entered wrong — a flat-out misspelling, first and last names swapped, and I insist on getting the email address corrected too, not just the display name. More than once, someone has waved it off: “oh, it’s fine, I’m used to it.” I know how that sounds, coming from someone who used to tell whole conference rooms not to bother. But there’s a difference between a room insisting on getting your name right for its own comfort, and fixing a system so you don’t have to keep correcting it. So I fix it anyway. It’s a small thing, and I don’t pretend it undoes anything about airports or background checks. But it’s the piece of this I actually have control over: insisting that a person’s name, exactly as they were given it, is worth the extra five minutes it takes to get right — the smallest possible refusal to make the mismatch someone else’s problem to manage.

REVIEW: The Incandescent by Emily Tesh (4-stars)

Another excellent Hugo nominee candidate for 2026, I'd have given this three stars right after finishing it — enjoyed it, moved on to read other books.  I kept turning this one over in my mind and just about every thread I pulled on turned out to be load-bearing. That's a four-star book. Bring on whatever Tesh does next.

"The Incandescent" sprinkles in some excellent humor throughout. I also listened to this partly as audio book and quite enjoyed the narration.  

Dr. Sapphire Walden runs Chetwood School's magic department the way you'd expect from someone who's spent two decades turning herself into an institution: forms, wards, risk assessments, six hundred teenagers with the theoretical capacity to accidentally summon something "approximately as destructive as a nuclear bomb." She's also got a tenth-order demon called the Phoenix bound into the tattoos on her arm, a decade-old leash she keeps because it's the only way she survived losing her boyfriend to a different demon at seventeen,at this same school. She says outright that she's the most powerful magician to ever walk through Chetwood's gates, and that's not incidental swagger. It's why she came back at all. This is the place that took Charlie from her as a student, and she's returned as the one person capable of standing between it and the student body, which makes the whole book as much a reckoning as it is a workplace story. On the surface this is dark academia with a competent forty-year-old at the wheel instead of a student, which is reason enough to read it. Underneath, it's doing something sneakier: the entire demon-containment premise is a metaphor for what Walden does to herself.

Start with the names: she's referred to as"Walden" like you would refer to someone in a news story, the military or sports team, or maybe this is normal for boys in UK public schools. It's a convention that gives her more authority than she feels her given first name would -- and creates distance dressed up as professionalism. "Dr. Walden" is a step further in, not out — the title she's earned and insists on from almost everyone, the credentialed self she holds up as a shield precisely because it can't be argued with. "Saffy" is the one people only get it after they've done something to earn actual vulnerability from her, not competence or tenure, and there aren't many of them.  She sees her given name "Sapphire" as too "pretty" and feminine; she feels exposed by it and doesn't feel comfortable to use it. Her family likely would be able to safely invoke that name whether she liked it or not. Four names, four escalating layers of control over how close anyone's allowed to get, and the book only lets you hear the real one in the handful of moments she stops managing herself long enough to be touched. In a book literally about invocation and binding — where naming a thing is how you control it — that's not incidental. She's doing to her own name exactly what she does to demons: containment through diminishment.

The Phoenix itself is the same impulse taken to its limit. She didn't just survive a demon encounter and get stuck with the thing, she summoned a tenth-order demon during her PhD research specifically to prove she could bind and control something that size, and then kept it leashed in her own skin for over a decade as a kind of walking dissertation defense. It's not a trauma she's managing, it's an achievement she engineered: the ultimate credential, proof that even the most dangerous thing imaginable can be made to sit obediently under her authority. Which makes it the purest version of the "Dr. Walden" persona there is, not armor she happened to acquire, but armor she built from scratch and can point to as evidence she never needs anyone.

Laura Kenning, the school's Chief Marshal, is the person who gets to see past the armor, and their slow burn is genuinely good: two extremely competent people sparking off each other in the middle of actual crises. She's also the one Walden is most helplessly attracted to, which is exactly the problem. Mark, by contrast, she essentially falls into bed with, and the book is careful to show that it's never more than that — a body she can keep at "Walden" distance the entire time, no real self on offer from either side. That's precisely why he's safe. He was never going to ask for Saffy. Laura is the one who might, and the book doesn't let this be easy: the second Laura gets pulled away and real intimacy becomes possible, Walden reflexively fills the vacancy with the person who requires nothing of her. It's the same reflex as the name, just played out physically instead: whatever's dangerous, whatever might actually get in, contain it or swap it for something smaller. Her past relationships get the same treatment in the way they're described; even in memory she keeps them at surname distance, competent and clipped, nothing that reads like she ever let anyone see more than "Dr. Walden" required.

The book also just proves the point through action, which I appreciated more than any amount of subtext could have managed on its own. Every time Walden is actually in danger, it's Laura who shows up and has her back, no hesitation, competence meeting competence. Laura even takes the fall after the first incident which is what takes her briefly out of Walden's orbit at Chetwood.  When Walden takes newly hired consultant (and uncle of a smarmy student) Mark out on a security check -- he disappears the second anything sketchy happens.  He's not backing her up, leaving her to handle it alone. So no, I did not feel bad when he ends up locked in stasis in the void. The man is a tool who vanishes the moment something requires him to actually be present for someone, and the book quietly lets his behavior in a crisis do what pages of interiority couldn't: show you exactly why he was never a real option, whatever Walden or the Phoenix told themselves about it.

The book is also very funny about all this, which keeps it from tipping into self-seriousness. The Phoenix, once actually let out to have opinions, puts Walden on a fitness regimen — not as discipline, but because its whole argument is "you have this body, use it, why are you just letting it sit there and run risk assessments." It's more pointed than a demon just liking bodies: the thing she summoned specifically to prove her own control is the one voice that keeps arguing against control as the goal, in favor of a woman who's spent twenty years treating her own body as infrastructure actually living in it instead. 

Later there's a gut-punch of a reveal that she's had Mark locked in stasis for months, which retroactively explains her blind spot: she wasn't fooled, she just handled the threat the only way she knows how, which is binding rather than confronting. What I found genuinely unsettling, though, is that the book never fully separates out whose call any of this was. She catches Mark stepping out with another colleague, and that seems to be the thing that tips the Phoenix but by that point Walden and the Phoenix are so fused that you can't tell where her own fury ends and the demon's takes over. Was the fitness regimen her, using the Phoenix as an excuse to finally treat her body like it's hers? Was locking Mark away her decision, or the Phoenix's, once it decided she couldn't be trusted to protect herself? The book doesn't answer that, and I don't think it's supposed to. It's the dissertation's whole premise coming back around: she proved she could control the Phoenix, and a decade later it's an open question whether the control was ever real, or whether it was hers to begin with. Not every demon in this book gets that kind of ambiguity, either — Old Faithful, who wears her dead boyfriend's face to torment her, is just monstrous, no interiority offered, and correctly gets fought rather than befriended. The book is careful about that distinction; it's not arguing everything scary is secretly fine if you just let it out, it's arguing you have to learn to tell the difference, even when the line runs straight through the middle of your own body.

There's a nice parallel running alongside all this in Nikki Conway, Walden's star student, whose own hesitation about leaving for university is running the same test at a different life stage — not "can I be loved" but "can I trust myself with more room than what already feels survivable." The book is smart enough not to make this a mentor-transmits-wisdom arc. Nikki doesn't learn from Walden's example; they're each stuck figuring out, independently, that the caution that once kept them alive has calcified into a ceiling. At the end of the story, they are both pecking those little cracks in their protective shells and preparing to spread their wings into something new and different - and I am cheering them on!



Monday, July 27, 2026

REVIEW: "The Ana and Din" mysteries, Books 1 & 2 by Robert Jackson Bennett

I have to confess, it took me a minute to really get into Tainted Cup—I picked it up and put it down (or let it expire off Libby) a few times well before the Hugos. One of my "Scent Head" friends who loves a good Diptyque candle came to visit me in July (and brought me a Diptyque candle) and told me how much he had really enjoyed the Ana and Din mysteries. I threw myself back into both books and I'm really glad I did.

It's a strange "bio-punk" kind of world—they have advanced gene editing and can (apparently) resurrect extinct races of intellectually superior but possibly less stable beings, but they don't have cell phones and use mycological solutions for HVAC and lighting (do they even have electricity?). One thing I'm not sure they do in this world is have FUN. Everything seems to be quite a lot of work to be part of this empire. Din has undergone some serious genetic changes in order to become an "engraver"—and he triggers his eidetic memory skills with scents. Ana, well, she's a different animal. Literally. One tic in this book is that her smile is repeatedly described as "predatory," which makes me think she must be smiling like an absolute lunatic (thinking Jack Nicholson in The Shining).

These are more detective novels than murder mysteries and the world-building is sometimes opaque and challenging to track, but that's why we have ebooks to search for words and recall context, I suppose. I also listened to the audiobooks for both of these books, and found them to be very enjoyable. 

Din is a dyslexic, tall, dark and handsome young man who isn't averse to surreptitiously picking up a few "skills" here and there to help with his investigations. He seems to be pansexual but has a same-sex romantic attachment from the first book, Tainted Cup. He also blows off steam by picking up one night stands.

Ana appears to be late middle-aged with wild white hair—a genius with yellow eyes like a wolf or a cat when she's not blindfolded to reduce stimulus. She fuels her genius for identifying patterns from Din's reports and the mountains of books she reads with a paleo diet of raw animal flesh in breathtaking quantities. While Din comes from a commoner background, Ana's background is a bit more mysterious—and it's a mystery she maintains on purpose, surprising Din with her ability to roleplay in the moment to manipulate social elites, and with the breadth and depth of her knowledge.

Ana is a savant operating on a totally different level from everyone around her. For example, when she tasks Din to visit the island where all the Leviathan extractions are processed and learns he will be wearing a full PPE suit with helmet, he worries about how he will be able to provide a proper report. Din can't easily supplement his memory with written notes the way other investigators might.  Ana has already solved the problem in a way Din never could have anticipated. It's the kind of moment that reminds you why she's indispensable: she thinks several moves ahead, in directions nobody else is even looking. And Din seems to be learning.

The map of the empire raises questions. In our world, we know where seals, sea lions and turtles come ashore to reproduce, or where salmon spawn and die. We work around those patterns to help avoid interspecies conflict. The people of this world build right in the path of these incredibly dangerous creatures (no two of them look the same) and put people in real jeopardy despite erecting massive walls and staffing them with trained military personnel.

There are defenses in concentric circles, with the most elite, protected areas in the first ring, farthest from the sea. Yet farther north at the top right of the map, we see no wall because the Leviathans don't come ashore there. There's also heaps of court intrigue and empire negotiations with a holdout kingdom—which holds the processing area for the Leviathans. It seems like everything this empire does is to create as much discomfort for the people as possible. It's always hot and wet, but people wear heavy wool uniforms that are incredibly uncomfortable. If it's practically a coastal jungle, why do they all have to wear heavy capes as part of their uniforms? The empire does not have the best interests of the people at heart. Obviously.

We are somewhat limited in our view of this world, from Din's perspective, which means we don't know what lies beyond the sea, or even to the west of the landmass we see on the map. Does anyone go there? What else is on this planet? Is it just one big landmass with a few islands off the coast? We aren't getting massive info dumps about "the whole world," which I appreciate a lot. This world is developed in a way that builds intrigue and lets me follow where Din is leading me.

While the main "mystery" is mostly solved early in A Drop of Corruption, the pair spend the rest of the story chasing the elusive killer and trying to pin down the connection to a massive bio-pharma plant that processes (and perhaps cultivates) the critical ingredients for the mysterious Leviathans that live in the adjacent sea—which form the basis of all the genetic modifications that people utilize in this world.

What I really liked is that both books wrapped up the primary problem and challenges by the end and along the way - the author built a foundation of details for the characters, their interiority and personalities that intrigued me and was able to keep that momentum going through the second book. I'm very much looking forward to the third book.


Saturday, July 25, 2026

REVIEW: A Drop of Corruption by Robert Jackson Bennett (4.5-stars)

 "A Drop of Corruption" is a detective novel masquerading as a mystery—which is to say, Bennett solves the central puzzle early and then uses the remaining 300 pages to chase a serial killer and a massive bio-pharma conspiracy. It works because the characters are this good.

Din is a dyslexic engraver whose eidetic memory triggers on scent. Ana is a wild-haired genius in her late middle years who reads obsessively and fuels her pattern-recognition with raw meat in staggering quantities. Their partnership is the book. When Din must enter a sterile bio-pharma clean room where his usual scent vials are forbidden, Ana creates a solution: a scent made from his sweat and the plants and leather of his PPE. It's the kind of detail that reveals everything about how completely she understands him.

The world-building is opaque and sometimes infuriating—how do they have gene-edited extinct races but no electricity? Why heavy wool uniforms in a coastal jungle? Why build walls in animal migration paths?—but that's intentional. We see only what Din sees. The empire is hostile and nonsensical because that's what empire does. It extracts maximum discomfort while calling it order. It doesn't have your best interests at heart. It never does.

Both the audiobook performances are excellent. The mystery doesn't break new ground, but the character work, the worldbuilding contradictions, and the relationship between Din and Ana are enough to carry you through and leave you wanting book three immediately.

REVIEW: A Drop of Corruption by Robert Jackson Bennett

RATING: 4.5-stars

Monday, July 06, 2026

REVIEW: What Moves the Dead by T. Kingfisher (5-stars)

 Yes, it's a retelling of Poe's "The Fall of the House of Usher." Yes, the premise is fairly well telegraphed the moment we meet Eugenia Potter, amateur mycologist (and — naturally — a relation of Beatrix). None of that stopped me from finishing this 150-page novella completely won over. I'll be damned if I can find a reason not to give it five stars.

The real triumph here is Alex Easton's first-person narration. Instead of leaning on atmosphere alone to do the work — the easy move for a haunted-house retelling — Kingfisher gives us a narrator with a distinct interior life: what Easton values, how they think, how they feel. It never tips into info-dumping, the prose is complex and nuanced without slowing the story down, and there are genuinely funny bits woven through the dread, which keeps the book from ever feeling like a pure mood exercise.

Easton's invented home country of Gallacia is a great example of worldbuilding done right — it's stitched skillfully into real European geography and history rather than floating free as a vague fantasy backdrop. One of my favorite small touches is the distinction Angus and the villagers draw between "canny" and "not canny." It's a tiny bit of invented cultural vocabulary that does a lot of heavy lifting, letting the book talk around the horror before it's ready to name it directly.

Compared to books it clearly sits alongside — Mexican Gothic, Invasion of the Body Snatchers — what sets this apart is how much empathy Kingfisher builds for her core cast: Easton, Denton, Potter, and Angus. I found myself genuinely invested in their outcomes, which isn't a given in this kind of "creeping wrongness" story, where the reader often figures things out well before the characters do. (Roderick and Madeline, unsurprisingly, get considerably less of that sympathy — as Poe fans would expect.)

I also can't stop thinking about how efficiently this book does everything it sets out to do. It's maybe 150 pages, and in that space it builds a fully realized main character, a functioning invented culture, a mystery, real dread, and real humor — with nothing that feels like padding. Which raises a question I keep coming back to: why can't YA do this? So much YA now comes in these 600-plus-page doorstoppers full of repetition and recontextualization, like the book doesn't trust the reader to have retained anything from fifty pages ago. There's nothing in What Moves the Dead that's explicitly "adult" — no content a teen reader couldn't handle — and I think it would genuinely appeal to kids who like goth and horror. The queerness in it works in a way that feels completely natural, not like an Issue being addressed, just part of who Easton is. It's a good reminder that "for teens" doesn't have to mean bloated, over-explained, or afraid to trust its reader.

The audiobook version was also quite engaging. I listened at 2x — it's a bit slow at normal speed — and kudos to the narrator for still sounding good at the faster pace.

A short book that does an enormous amount with its page count. Highly recommended, especially if you're a Poe fan or you liked Mexican Gothic. Looking forward to the next two books in the series, and then on to the Ana and Din duology.

REVIEW: What Moves the Dead by T. Kingfisher 
RATING: 5-stars

POSTSCRIPT: This is the second “retelling” of a well known story that I have completed this summer in my Hugos quest. I also read Cinder House by Freya Marske, another Hugo nominee, this one a retelling of Cinderella — also short, and also a genuinely fun, relatable, enjoyable spin on a story everyone already thinks they know. Between the two of them, I'm impressed by how much these authors have managed to take classic stories and folk material and turn them into something that feels different, but is still just as engaging and fun as the source material. It's a nice reminder that a retelling doesn't need extra length to earn its place — it needs a clear point of view on the original.



Sunday, July 05, 2026

REVIEW: Oathbound by Tracey Deonn (2-stars)

I read Legendborn and Bloodmarked specifically because Oathbound is a Hugo nominee. Without that context, I wouldn't understand the extent of what's gone wrong.

The most obvious sign is textual. Across the trilogy, Deonn relies on a single formulaic construction to describe facial expressions: [facial feature] + quirk/quirked. In Legendborn, this appears 8 times. In Bloodmarked, 7 times. In Oathbound, it escalates to 15 instances (14 "mouth quirks," 1 "eyebrow quirking"). A human writer naturally varies: smirk, grin, curve, twist, tighten, narrow. Instead, this book locks into a template structure applied across different body parts, which could be a tell that the author is reading a lot of romantasy (I read somewhere it's a trendy term) or just has an editing blind spot. This pattern escalation across a 656-page book is not stylistic choice; it's mechanical repetition. But the textual issues point to larger structural collapse.

The book abandons every piece of emotional infrastructure established in the previous books. Bree's father doesn't appear at all. There's no acknowledgment of where he's been while his daughter has been missing for 8-12 months. Alice, who was observant and strategic in the previous book, is injured and falls into a coma where she is reliving her own death in some kind of purgatory-equivalent. Alice appears to exist only as motivation for Mariah's quest and involvement in the plot tangles. Edwin, Bree's father, gets brought back extremely late in the book through an enchanted ring that connects him with his dead wife. He goes willingly because of that spiritual connection. But then he just disappears from the narrative. He's acknowledged just enough to close a plot loop, then discarded.

This third book doesn't resolve the actual story. Bree entered a mentor-protégé relationship with the Shadow King. She chose to stay with him, to self-erase her memories of her other life to become "untouchable." That's psychologically complex territory: what happens when a traumatized girl decides the only way to survive is to disappear into power. But the book doesn't interrogate that. Instead it piles on seventeen other threads: the Crown, the collectors' auction, the gene therapy conspiracy, the trafficking of underage magical girls, the Whodunnit hotel lockdown. The actual story, the psychological fallout of Bree's choice to erase herself, gets buried under plot noise.

Descriptions of clothing and hair that aren't thematic anymore.  There are multiple paragraphs just describing outfits. There’s repeated backstory repeating from previous books, and internally (at least three sections describing a Medium’s capabilities).  In this book – the first person narration rotates across a pile of secondary characters including Natasia, William, Mariah, & Nick – a choice that dilutes rather than deepens Bree’s story. Natasia's chapters don't advance understanding; they just add pages. Emil is introduced, solves a plot problem by tunneling underground, and disappears with Bree's relief. He's a plot device, not a character.

The gender breakdown bothers me: all the root craft practitioners -- save Emil, who exists only to move earth -- are women. If that's intentional, it's saying something about gendered access to certain magic. Root magic as women's magic. That could be sophisticated thematic work. Instead, it's just there, unexamined.

The trafficking element also bothers me. Why underage magical girls? Why not adults with suppressed or latent powers? An adult woman on antidepressants who doesn't know she has access to root craft—that's a story about how medical systems suppress female power. Or even menopausal women who can’t figure out why they feel the way they do (it is the opposite end of teenage development afterall, leaving fertility vs moving into fertility). Instead, Deonn targets children who can be "shaped" into tools. One is a story about reclamation. The other is a story about containment. She chose containment.

The heteronormativity is frustrating. Bree's caught in a love triangle between Nick and Selwyn, and the book treats it as inevitable that she must choose one or the other. Why can't she be in love with both of them? Why can't they agree to share? The book forces a binary choice for no reason except to enforce cultural norms of jealousy.

The conclusion doesn't resolve anything. The Whodunnit hotel lockdown where the host tortures and kills people on stage while guests stand around under mesmerizing forces? The logic falls apart. Why would anyone stay? The Crown turns out to be a Maguffin. The Shadow King bargain has vague consequences. The whole thing feels like it was written under severe time pressure—plot beats checked off, character arcs abandoned, thematic work buried under filler.

I'm rating this 2 stars because a Hugo nominee should demand better editing, better structural decision-making, and a clearer understanding of what story it's actually telling. This book does none of those things. It's 656 pages of potential buried under padding and pattern repetition. The fact that no one seems to be asking whether this was AI-assisted—or at minimum heavily revised under deadline—is its own problem.

REVIEW: Oathbound by Tracey Deonn 

RATING: 2-stars



Saturday, July 04, 2026

REVIEW: Bloodmarked by Tracey Deonn (2.5 stars)

 Legendborn set up something genuinely specific: a 16-year-old who's grieving, intellectually advanced enough to do early college, suddenly pulled into a hidden magical world. She's fitting in with older students, proving herself academically, dealing with her mother's death, and managing phone calls from her dad who grounds her in reality. That friction between normal teen life and exceptional circumstances is what made the first book work.

Bloodmarked expands the world, but it loses the girl at the center of it. Halfway through this book, college has become scenery. Her father is barely present. The smart teen navigating exceptional circumstances—which is actually rich territory—gets flattened into magical plot escalation. The grief becomes motivation rather than something Bree is actually processing.

The ancestral magic system is genuinely interesting and represents the book's strongest footing. Vera was the enslaved first ancestor who made the original deal—a prayer for safety and protection while pregnant and escaping. The Hunter heard that prayer, hijacked it, and agreed to a pact that binds every daughter in her lineage, including Bree, to him forever (aside:  seems like a major disincentive to pray if it's a party line with eavesdropping demons). The women in Bree's bloodline have all died relatively young—some in childbirth—and they were warned to avoid tapping into the ancestral power altogether, trying to shield their daughters from the death sentence they inherited. But Bree, as the King, can't avoid it. She has to use the very power that's killing her bloodline. Arthur himself possesses Bree at times, another layer of violation and control over her body. She has to fight her way out of his dream world with Nick and Selwyn to reclaim her own agency. 

That's sophisticated territory: how a Black woman inherits not just power but the violence embedded in that power—slavery, rape, a demonic pact, and a curse of early death. The book also explores how demons exploit language in negotiations, preferring to leave things open-ended while those with less power have to be meticulous with every word. Accessing the magic costs your life. It's sharp work about how power structures exploit vulnerability. Bree's hair as an expression of her power is thematically sharp too. When she channels energy, her carefully styled hair erupts wild and loose. That's not just description; that's her interiority made visible. The gene therapy element adds something sinister.

But then Bree burns it all down at the climax. She destroys her ancestral streams. It's devastating and desperate and born from real rage. And then the book doesn't actually explore that. Instead of sitting with the psychological and magical fallout of severing all connection to her ancestors—which is genuinely complex territory—Book 2 just piles on more plot. More magic system exposition. More descriptions of clothing and hair that aren't doing any thematic work. More repeated explanations of what a "Medium" is, as if readers forgot. 

The structural problems run deeper. Two 16-year-olds in an early college program, away from home, in a dorm with minimal adult oversight, participate in hazing rituals that cause serious physical injury. The only adults present are either distant and ineffective or openly hostile to Bree's authority. The Order itself—the secret society that's supposed to accept her based on their own rules and traditions —doesn't accept a Black girl as their King. That institutional racism and sexism is a wall the teenagers have to battle from within their own organization. Bree's grandmother living in her head is not parental protection; it's neglect with a magical gloss. Her father was her emotional anchor in book 1. In book 2, he's gone. 

When the malicious adults on campus become a direct threat, they flee and end up as a “last resort” at The Crossroads, a supernatural bar where they encounter a Cambion proprietor in their search for the story’s equivalent of a powerful sorceresss in the rootcraft world. Alice does heavy lifting here - she's observant, strategic, worried about real-world consequences. She sees fraud being committed by an employee and uses that information to negotiate their way out with the proprietor. She saves them. And then at the final battle at the climax - Alice gets injured and falls into a coma. Her competence is demonstrated and then she's neutralized and completely sidelined for the next book. She ends up as a plot device or motivation for other people's quests (like Mariah). That's not character development. That's abandonment of the infrastructure that made book 1 matter. 

The romantic intensity described here reads like an adult's fantasy of what teen attraction should feel like, not what it actually is. The book expects this restrained physicality to carry emotional weight it hasn't earned through interiority.

And there's the Morgaine/Morgana problem: Deonn perpetuates the patriarchal Arthurian trope where Morgana has to be the villain. Marion Zimmer Bradley showed decades ago that you can retell this legend by centering Morgaine's agency and politics. Instead, the Morgaines here are just malicious adults extracting value from the young. They're not complex. They're functional antagonists. That was a choice.

Ultimately, Bloodmarked had the bones of a stronger book. The ancestral magic system was compelling. The college setting grounded the magical stakes. The grief was real. The smart teen navigating both normal and exceptional pressures was genuinely worth exploring. But instead of deepening those threads, the book widened the magical plot and lost the girl. It set up a devastating choice about ancestral connection and then buried the fallout under 400 pages of unnecessary description and repeated exposition. 

I'm rating this 2.5 because the potential is there. But the execution abandoned the original premise that mattered.



Friday, July 03, 2026

REVIEW: "The Millay Illusion" by Sarah Pinsker (3-stars)

Hugo nominated novelette "The Millay Illusion" is really engaging and well written. On the surface it’s about stage magic in the early 1900s; underneath it’s about gender, power, and how a system can erase a woman even while applauding her tricks. The style reminded me modern period stories about women who are navigating complex social structures that don't benefit or recognize them (such as "Tipping the Velvet).  As a reader, I was pulled into our narrator's story and felt like I was led off a bit of a cliff at the end. There's a lot of ambiguity that may polarize readers into "loved it" or "hated it."

The narrator, "Lottie," accepts the roles that men put her into - whether it's her father deciding she travel as "Julius" or her uncle deciding within minutes of meeting her she'll be "Johnny Chess." She is trained to notice details to predict behavior and manipulate her audience. Then she meets Susanna who joins the troupe at age 15. 

Susanna the only person in the story doing anything genuinely new, and of course she’s the one the men dismiss, steal from, and eventually push out. Our narrator — a mentalist who prides herself on noticing everything — misses the actual point entirely. She can read a stranger’s tells but can’t recognize patriarchy even when she’s lugging buckets for it. She inherits Susanna’s act without inheriting any of her courage, which is the saddest part of the whole thing.

As for the Hugo nomination: this is exactly the kind of story the Hugos love. It’s not about the magic tricks; it’s about the system around them. It’s about how women disappear from history while someone else performs their work “the proper way.” It’s subtle, it’s sharp, and it’s doing more than it looks like at first glance.

If you like stories where the narrator is competent in all the wrong ways, this one’s worth the read - you can find it on the Uncanny Magazine website here: https://www.uncannymagazine.com/article/the-millay-illusion/


REVIEW:  "The Millay Illusion" by Sarah Pinsker 

RATING: 3-stars

Thursday, July 02, 2026

REVIEW: "Legendborn" by Tracey Deonn (3-stars)

This was my first Tracy Deonn book — I’m reading the series because the third one is a Hugo nominee — and Oathbound definitely gives me the context I needed. The worldbuilding is ambitious: grief, generational trauma, and a whole modern network of Arthurian descendants (apparently thousands of them, mostly in the U.S.) operating out of UNC like a magical Highlander chapter. There’s even a Hunger Games–style competition element, where the fate of the world hinges on getting the right supporters aligned with the right scions.

I alternated between audiobook and ebook, and the “Southern” accents in the audio were rough. I lived in the South for four years, and these sounded more like caricatures than actual regional voices.

The YA framing also feels strained. These are 16‑year‑olds in dorms with almost no adult oversight, navigating hazing, injuries, and adult‑coded emotional intensity. Bree’s grandmother “in her head” is meant to function as guidance, but it reads more like narrative neglect. The racialized “blood vs root” magic divide doesn’t hold up under scrutiny — both sides bind, both gatekeep, both hide their histories — so the binary feels more ideological than real.

There’s also a lot of focus on hair, clothes, and outfits. I know this is a common YA trope, but it doesn’t add much here. The scene where Bree tries on eleven dresses for a fancy secret‑society gala wasn’t tense — just personally terrifying to me. I’ve never understood why these books treat dress‑up moments as emotionally essential; it feels like padding rather than character insight.

As a GenX reader who grew up on The Mists of Avalon, I’m also tired of the default patriarchal trope where Morgaine/Morgana’s descendants are automatically coded as “evil.” Deonn didn’t have to perpetuate that. Given that the first book already revealed that people in power were lying — and were responsible for opening the hell gate — I’m hoping the Morgaine lineage is another place where the official story is false and we’re going to see that lie unravel in later books.

But overall, I did think this was an interesting Arthurian retelling. Making a young girl the “King” — and having Arthur literally possess her — adds a compelling gender‑transcendent angle to the myth. The way characters refer to Bree as their King is one of the more refreshing updates to the Arthurian canon.

I appreciate the way Deonn reimagines Arthurian power through Bree — not just in terms of gender, but perceived race. Having a young Black girl become “King,” and having Arthur literally possess her, reframes the myth in a way that acknowledges slavery, rape, escape, and generational trauma while also redefining who gets to inherit power. It’s one of the more interesting updates to the Arthurian world, and I’m curious to see how far the series pushes that idea.

Interesting world, uneven execution. I just hope the next books don’t repeat too much backstory (a la late‑series Harry Potter, which bloats with recap every volume).

REVIEW: "Legendborn" by Tracey Deonn

RATING: 3-stars