Showing posts with label 2.5-stars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2.5-stars. Show all posts

Thursday, October 08, 2026

REVIEW: Queen of Faces by Petra Lord (2.5 stars)

 The premise hooked me: the “pith” is the person and the body is just a chassis you drive. But the worldbuilding never earns it. Memory, language, and even personhood turn out to be editable or winnable in contests, yet the book also insists that a bad body will kill you, so the metaphor strains against its own plot. And nobody ever asks who makes these bodies. Scalzi’s Old Man’s War shows you the engineering and the branding, and Bennett’s biotech has a visible supply chain. Here, fully functional bodies just show up.

The “humdrum” label felt needlessly pejorative to me, especially once you learn magic is a learnable skill. The divide is access to training, not nature, which makes the contempt look like class snobbery in costume. The same goes for the “Edgar” brand for the cheap male chassis, which was a smart touch of shaming through vocabulary.

I wanted more from the gender angle. Ten years in a male body while living as a girl, and Nell being forced into one, gave the story real stakes. But the body market offers only two models, both built to a narrow, pale, lean beauty standard. For a world where you can choose your body, that’s an oddly limited menu, and the book doesn’t seem interested in questioning it.

The bigger picture reads as a totalitarian regime: it can erase names, wipe a people’s language until they drown themselves, and ration magic through one academy. All of that is more compelling than the surface plot. As for the blood and torture in a YA book, the darkness fits the themes, but it sometimes felt like escalation rather than insight.

Interesting ideas, thin foundations. I’d read the sequel only if it finally shows where the bodies come from and find out whether Nell decides she was happier in a "boy" body.

REVIEW: Queen of Faces by Petra Lord (2.5 stars)

Tuesday, September 22, 2026

REVIEW: "Bodies of Magic" by Freya Marske (2.5)

I loved Freya Marske's The Cinder House. It created characters and a world that were interesting, funny and the story structure allowed for their growth.  This resulted in a working found family situation for the main protagonists. When I picked up Bodies of Magic, I was hoping for more. Maybe something along the lines of The Incandescent, which I adored. Instead, I got something along the lines of The Raven Scholar.

And you know what? That might just mean it's not my genre, which is fine. Preferences are real.

But there's a problem underneath the tone and pacing that goes deeper than genre mismatch. It's about what the book borrows and what it refuses to reckon with.

Bodies of Magic has a genuinely compelling mystery at its core: a brilliant student is dead, and there are institutional incentives to hide the death: keep students enrolled another year, keep the funding flowing, protect the academy's reputation. That's a meaty plot. There's real corruption there, real stakes. The detective work of uncovering what happened and why the institution had reason to want fail talented students training to meet a role that is in short supply in their world is really the book could sing.

And parts of it do. The mystery itself works. But the execution fractures everywhere else.

The protagonists swing between reading as young teenagers and college students gone wild -- not convincingly as both, not even convincingly as either one. The resolution doesn't feel earned; the villain makes a confession in front of a room of people without the setup to land it. The supporting cast feels ineffectual in ways that undermine rather than complicate the narrative.

These are craft problems, and they're real problems. But underneath them sits something that troubles me more.

In the real world -- the one you and I live in, the one Freya Marske lives in -- there are people who believe that physical illness can be healed through metaphysical, spiritual, or faith-based means instead of medicine. This isn't a metaphor. It isn't a thought experiment. It's a functioning ideology with practitioners and consequences.

Christian Science. Medical neglect in faith-healing churches. Anti-vax communities. The logic is the same: the body can be healed by belief, by prayer, by spiritual alignment, or, in this book's framing, by having the right magical gift.

The novel's portrayal of "healers" who cure illness through magical circles, humming, and singing risks romanticizing faith healing while overlooking its real-world consequences. Medical neglect is not limited to refusing vaccines; it can mean denying children doctors, hospitals, diagnostic tests, appropriate medicines, and even basic treatment for fever and pain. When serious illnesses are left untreated, the result can be preventable death, permanent hearing loss, neurological injury, developmental or behavioral difficulties, chronic disability, and lifelong suffering. The fantasy may present healing rituals as effective, but in real life, replacing evidence-based medical care with prayer or ritual can have devastating consequences, especially for children who cannot make that choice for themselves.

This is the ideology Bodies of Magic borrows and validates. The book tries to create distance by inventing fictitious ailments (phantomes, for instance) but it doesn't create enough distance. The logic remains unchanged: the body can be healed through non-material, non-scientific means, without ever engaging with how medicine actually works. The mechanism is magic instead of prayer, but the underlying delusion is identical.

The worldbuilding picks and chooses what exists based on plot convenience and aesthetic preference, not coherence.

Consider the infrastructure: the book includes hospitals, gyms, boxing clubs, self-defense training, pianos, and institutional bureaucracy sophisticated enough to set retirement ages at 70. Healers are revered as an elite, essential profession, yet they coexist with all these other systems. Why would a society have hospitals if magical healing works? Why gyms, why physical training, why concern about bodies at all? Why pianos and gymnasiums but also medieval garments and archaic names? Why sophisticated enough institutions to raise the retirement age, but not sophisticated enough to have a postal service—relying instead on wax seals on messenger-delivered notes?

While there's a non-binary character -- there's also repeated references to "whorish" as a pejorative descriptor (esp as related to short hair styles - sort of a 1950s/medieval-coded misogyny and shame-based sexual control) interspersed with olympian sexual exploits across characters.

Compare this to Ursula K. Le Guin's Earthsea, where magic students attend school and academy but remain embedded in society.  These magicians are revered for their skill as they would be for any other trade, integrated rather than separated, valued and relied upon as essential workers. That's a coherent world.

Bodies of Magic doesn't want coherence. It wants the aesthetic of medieval oppression (archaic clothing, gendered shame, class hierarchy, elite separation) layered over modern institutional infrastructure (hospitals, gyms, retirement systems). It borrows the visual and emotional texture of oppression without committing to understanding what any of it actually means.

And the faith-healing system is just the most ideologically charged example of this pattern.  The world also features elite hoarding of essential services as window dressing -- entire geographic areas are without proper medical care in this world.

By treating magical medicine as a functional, glamorous reality for an elite group of college students, the narrative unintentionally validates the internal logic of real-world faith healers. It proposes a world where the people who reject standard medicine are actually right—they just have access to something better. Everyone else just doesn't have the gift.

For anyone who has lived with the devastating, permanent consequences of that real-world delusion, this doesn't read as a fun magical escape. 

I'm not arguing that fantasy needs literal scientific accuracy. A hyperdrive is ridiculous. Enchanted swords are ridiculous. Dragons are ridiculous. Fantasy invents abstract impossibilities constantly, and that's the entire point.

But there's a difference between inventing an impossibility and borrowing a real-world ideology that has a body count.

A hyperdrive doesn't exist, and no one is dying because their parents tried to build one instead of taking them to the ER. It's pure invention. Harmless imagination.

A system where physical illnesses are treated through metaphysical, spiritual, or faith-based means? That's not pure invention. That's stepping directly into territory occupied by real, living people who use that exact logic to justify medical neglect.

The distinction isn't about realism. It's about tonal responsibility. When you borrow a real-world delusion that actively kills children and wrap it in aspirational, lighthearted narrative, you're not creating a fun alternate magic system. You're fulfilling a fantasy of a world where the people who reject medicine are actually right. That's not a neutral choice.

Bodies of Magic isn't a bad book. It has solid mystery structure, and the author clearly knows how to craft a narrative (see: The Cinder House).

But the premise is irresponsible, and the execution doesn't reckon with that irresponsibility. The tone stays light. The romance keeps the focus on interpersonal drama rather than systemic harm. The resolution is neat and unsatisfying.

2.5 stars feels right: good bones undone by a lack of tonal responsibility.

Maybe that's fine for readers who come to fantasy for escape and aren't carrying the specific trauma of having watched faith-healing ideology destroy people they love. Maybe for those readers, magical medicine is just another ridiculous trope, no different from a hyperdrive.

Friday, September 11, 2026

REVIEW: Too Like the Lightning by Ada Palmer (2.5 stars)

Palmer teaches medieval history to college students, and it shows: "Too Like the Lightning" feels as though it was written for readers encountering these ideas (gender beyond binary, transgressive religion, questioning power structures) for the first time. The book might feel revelatory to them. For anyone with any kind of background in social sciences, philosophy, organizational behavior, or critical theory, it's overlong and under-rewarding.

But the core problem isn't the audience mismatch. It's that Palmer has written a book describing totalitarianism and presented it as a utopia -- but nobody in the book seems to know the difference.

Mycroft is established as an unreliable narrator from the start, but the specifics of his crimes -- a weeklong killing/torture spree of his chosen family motivated by messianic delusion -- don't surface until late. The society's response was to elevate him into the ruling elite's inner circle, where he functions as a sophisticated pet: allowed to witness high-level meetings, observe from closets, provide intelligence, but always at their sufferance. He's kept close because he's intelligent and useful, not because he's a visionary.

The majority of this book is a detective story. The investigation into a stolen political document (the Seven-Ten List) uncovers something far darker: the Saneer-Weeksbooth bash has been conducting systematic political assassinations, justified as necessary to maintain world peace.  Martin Guildbreaker and Papadelias uncover a state-level assassination conspiracy, apparently running on the exact same messianic logic and hidden as accidental deaths in a highly regulated flying car system.

I personally didn't connect with any of the characters - Mycroft is creepy and gross at best, alternating between sniveling obsequiousness, or creepy obsession (ie repeated mentions of dark Indian skin), with tender parental concern over Bridger.  

Then there's Bridger: a 13-year-old alien with god-like reality-warping powers who acts like a 4-year-old and wants to sit on adult laps. He can draw a potion on paper and manifest it. He can resurrect the dead, turn plush toys into living animals. But Palmer gives him no actual imagination or agency. He doesn't explore what else he can do. He doesn't test his powers or question his dependency. He just sits passively, infantilized and underutilized.   Don't even get me started on JEDD Mason and Dominic Seneschal.

There are many genetic advancements - people can change their physical gender if they like but they are still in a psot-gender society (despite Mycroft's obsession with using binary gender pronouns). Or consider the centipede cat: multiple segmented bodies, supposedly a marvel of this future world. Except Mycroft describes it wrapping around both your ankles and spiraling onto your lap for petting and snuggles—exactly what a regular four-legged cat already does. The elaborate construction delivers no functional difference, just complication for its own sake.  Why not create cats who enjoy improved health with aging - without kidney disease, lymphoma, diabetes or dental issues.

And Palmer never interrogates what it would actually mean to have a multi-segmented creature loose in public -- tripping people, risking injury to itself or bicyclists—assuming anyone even bikes, which they don't seem to, because there's no evidence of embodied physical life in this "utopia." No exercise. No nature engagement, though some of the people like to include elaborate representations of nature on their clothing. Aside from Mycroft torturing someone in the Antarctic, we don't hear much about outdoor activity. Just people in cities and buildings absorbing data and ideas while a totalitarian system monitors their every movement.

The book describes this as a utopia worth saving. Mycroft narrates it as enlightenment nerd. But what's actually on the page: a totalitarian system run by hedonistic elites that keeps a serial killer as a prized pet and a god-like alien child as an infantilized tool. Everyone monitored. Nature abstracted into fashion. The "solutions" (kitchen trees, meat machines) eliminate visible labor without solving underlying constraints. There's no actual life, just the performance of transcendence.

If Palmer intended this as a critique of how totalitarian systems normalize themselves through the eyes of those benefiting from them, it needs to be much clearer. If she actually believes the utopia Mycroft is selling, then the book is inadvertently propaganda for totalitarianism.

Either way, it's overwritten, underpaced, and unwilling to interrogate what it's actually describing. The ambition is real. The execution isn't there.

Friday, September 04, 2026

REVIEW: The A.R.C.: A Virus That Kills When You Lie by Tim Disney (2.5 stars)

 I picked this up free at WorldCon. It was shrink-wrapped, so I couldn't preview it, and the $45 price on the back suggests I got a bargain. I'm not sure I did.

"A virus that kills you when you lie" is a terrific engine for satire, and I wanted this to be sharper than it is. The hardcover is beautifully produced, and the art is a real strength, which makes it more disappointing that the writing doesn't match. The idea is more or less the whole book. The plot is thin, the characters are barely sketched, and the rules never settle. Some people die instantly while others linger long enough to save themselves by telling the truth. Is that tied to the size of the lie? The liar? Pure convenience? Without an answer, the story can't build real tension or say anything pointed about who gets punished for lying.

In the cruise ship subplot, the book's only gay couple is clearly identified as gay, and one of them says "I love you," insists it's true, and dies anyway, so the virus rules that he was lying. Meanwhile, a husband and wife who admit they're out of love, but say they want to make it work, are treated as telling the truth. Whatever the intent, the result is that the only gay characters in the book are the ones whose love is declared fake, while a straight couple who admit they're out of love get to live. It also undercuts the premise, since the virus is supposed to punish lies, not sincerity, and it makes the rules feel even more arbitrary.

At the end there are several pages of rants about the problems of cruise ships. The cruise ship material is a fair target, and I have no objection to a screed against the industry. But the small island opening artillery on a cruise ship struck me as violence with no comic or thematic payoff.

The bigger problem is the book's treatment of women. There's a Benny Hill-style gag in which a man falls face first into a woman's chest and greets it with "Good morning, America." Beyond that, the "attractive" women are wasp-waisted with enormous breasts, and nearly everyone else is either old and ugly or old and fat. Satire is supposed to punch at power and hypocrisy. This reproduces the tropes it could have mocked, and it made the book feel dated, misogynist, and mean-spirited. It wasn't the only graphic novel I picked up at WorldCon that leaned on the same stereotypes in place of characters, and it's a shame, because the premise here deserved better.

The "obituary" section, with portraits of billionaires and politicians who die from the virus, is where the book's spite is most on display. Powerful liars are a fair target, and this could have been the payoff of the premise. But there's no context for what any of these people lied about or why they earned it, so it reads like the authors' personal wishlist instead of satire. A rogues gallery isn't a punchline.

The final section, an alternate history in which Robert Kennedy becomes president, is heavy on gags and tropes and light on substance. Good alt-history satire uses the changes to say something about our world, and this mostly piles on jokes.

The book closes with quotes about truth from a run of notable men, then one from a woman named Dailey, who says the truth shouldn't get in the way of a good story. I couldn't verify her, so I can't say whether the choice was a clever wink at the reader or just how the closing page fell together. Either way, it fits a book about the slippery relationship between truth and stories.

A handsome package around an underdeveloped idea. I'd suggest skipping it and waiting for a better use of this premise.

REVIEW: The A.R.C.: A Virus That Kills When You Lie by Tim Disney
RATING: 2.5 stars

Sunday, August 23, 2026

REVIEW: The West Passage by Jared Pechaček (2.5 stars)

Another book from my Hugo Nominee reading list and while I made it through this book, I'm still not entirely sure what I read.

On the surface, Pell (who becomes the abbess, Yarrow) and Kew (who becomes the guardian Hawthorne and changes from boy to woman) are teens thrust into roles with responsibilities they aren't quite prepared to handle. They both go off on quests to help save their home and we follow their adventures through Red, Yellow, Blue and Black tower controlled regions.  The Beast is awakening and winter has come too early and the other sisters / Lady creatures have to be "warned."  What will they do? Will they help or is this just part of the cycle that they expect?

The premise, once you start looking for it, is actually pretty dark. The West Passage is basically a closed system where people are manufactured through ritual consumption. There are these giant beings called the Ladies, and they're not really rulers; they're products. Made from honey that's derived from processed human remains (mellified man, which is apparently a delicacy that cures illness). Ravens in Grey Tower tear the bodies down and fly off - though we don't have visibility into this process, I suspect that the flesh goes into special honey.  There are even more special types of honey (like thistle) that create or pacify the Lady creatures. Some people are "simple skin" people - but a lot of people are chimerical with rabbit ears, trout heads, tree branches for hair, or very owl-like and laying eggs.  Everyone enjoys honey and mead as a regular part of their diet - but specific "vintages" or types of honey are reserved for the Lady creatures.  At least one Lady creature has a poisonous bite and will eat other Lady creatures.

The Beast everyone's afraid of? It's the 6th Lady, the source of the whole system, been sleeping/imprisoned under Grey Tower the whole time. When the system starts failing and she wakes up, the "victory" is basically: accept what you are. Hawthorne (who is Kew transformed) goes inside a giant tree. Yarrow goes back to Grey Tower to continue her role as Mother/abbess of the birth/death doulas.  Does the cycle keep going? Does something else happen? That's a genuinely interesting premise. 

For me, the problem is that even with the medieval art style illustrations,  I can't really picture what these creatures look like.The illustrations help, but you're reading 500 pages where you're asked to hold incomprehensible morphologies in your head while the narrative moves through dream logic. There's no conventional plot. Characters have no interiority — and I realize now that's kind of the point (they're products of a system, not people), but it doesn't make them engaging to read about.

The ending is resignation, not resolution. Yarrow knows now. She goes back anyway. That's bleak, but it's also just... static.

Compared to Perdido Street Station, which I gave Perdido 3 stars partly because Miéville does similar territory — massive city built in/on a dead creature, systemic oppression, strange biology — but he makes it inhabitable. You can see those ribs on the horizon. Isaac and Lin have interiority and actually choose things that matter. The weirdness is immersive, not obscuring.

The West Passage uses obscurity as its central feature. The dream logic, the baroque description, the resistance to conventional narrative — that's intentional. Some people will find that captivating. I found it exhausting.

The book has an audacious premise underneath, but it's buried under 500 pages that could've been half that length. Pechaček prioritized concept over character, atmosphere over clarity. I don't find myself invested enough in what happens next to pick up a sequel, if there is one.  "The West Passage" was built to be analyzed and argued over - more than enjoyed.  With that in mind, I'm sure this will be an excellent book for discussion in a book club or in a college lit course.

REVIEW: The West Passage by Jared Pechaček
RATING: 2.5 stars