Monday, May 10, 2010

REVIEW: The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo (Millennium #1) by Stieg Larsson (1-star)

It took me nearly 400 page to start to care about what was going on in this book - since I was a languages major, I always read through and confess to having read the last 40 pages or so when I was around page 250. 

 First, I have to say that this book could stand some real editing down. I agree with folks that it's hard to understand what the monetary values are - it would have been nice to have a little appendix with some of the figures - at the date this is set Kronor = X pounds = X dollars or whatever. 

 I didn't find the names of the characters all that confusing as some of the other reviewers did - names are just names, people! But why didn't they translate "Ms" - unless "Froken" has some hidden meaning - perhaps they should have explained the cultural context and the reason for not translating that in an appendix. 

 Yes - it was irritating to continually read gratuitous references of Mac hardware and applications (a URL in the book to a freeware app, REALLY???). I agree with Anne's review of the movie - why did they change the name? "Men Who Hate Women" is much more appropriate. The parallel character development - Martin and Lisbeth - was just not that well done. I have to admit when the book described how handsome he is - I was a bit amazed at the frumpy plain looking middle aged guy they picked to play Martin in the movie! 

 Despite the gore and violence depicted in the book - in the end, it felt like a lukewarm and overly long setup to create a super smart female hacker protagonist who embezzles money from a criminal to live happily ever after spending freely and traveling wherever she wants. 

 *yawn* 

 Another Cinderella story. Next, please!

REVIEW: The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo (Millennium #1) by Stieg Larsson 
RATING: 1-star

No comments: